216digital.
Web Accessibility

ADA Risk Mitigation
Prevent and Respond to ADA Lawsuits


WCAG & Section 508
Conform with Local and International Requirements


a11y.Radar
Ongoing Monitoring and Maintenance


Consultation & Training

Is Your Website Vulnerable to Frivolous Lawsuits?
Get a Free Web Accessibility Audit to Learn Where You Stand
Find Out Today!

Web Design & Development

Marketing

PPC Management
Google & Social Media Ads


Professional SEO
Increase Organic Search Strength

Interested in Marketing?
Speak to an Expert about marketing opportunities for your brand to cultivate support and growth online.
Contact Us

About

Blog

Contact Us
  • YouTube Accessibility: Captions, Audio, and Design

    Most teams watch views, watch time, and subscribers like hawks. But there is another number that matters, even if you never see it in analytics. How many people tried to watch your video and left because it was hard to follow?

    That question sits at the heart of YouTube accessibility.

    YouTube is one of the biggest marketing channels most brands rely on. It powers product explainers, support content, training, webinars, and the videos embedded on your website. When the video is hard to use, that friction follows your brand.

    Now, YouTube does a few things well out of the box. The player is responsive, the controls are built in, and keyboard shortcuts are already there. Screen reader support is strong, too. Still, the creator side matters most. Captions, transcripts, audio description, visual design, structure, and testing are all handled by your team. None of this needs to be complicated, and it scales well once it’s part of your workflow.

    Start With a Plan for YouTube Accessibility

    If accessibility starts after the upload, it usually turns into cleanup work. Cleanup is slower. It costs more. It also leads to compromises, like leaving a confusing visual in place because the edit timeline is already locked.

    Planning earlier changes the whole experience. When you build accessibility into the script and storyboard, you can:

    • Read on-screen text out loud as you write it.
    • Explain charts and visuals in the same moment they appear.
    • Avoid abrupt effects that some viewers may not handle.
    • Save time by choosing caption and transcript steps up front.

    Set a Baseline and Assign Ownership

    A simple shift helps. Treat accessibility checkpoints like production milestones. Put them beside script approval, rough cut, and final cut. When a team does this, rework drops fast, especially for repeat formats like weekly updates or a recurring demo series.

    It also helps define a baseline for each video type. A solid default for prerecorded content often includes accurate captions, a transcript viewers can access outside the player, and narration that explains important visuals. Then you layer in needs by format. Tutorials often need stronger descriptive narration. Short marketing clips need careful contrast and motion choices. Webinars and livestreams need reliable audio and a caption plan.

    This is also about roles. Every script needs a clear owner. Captions deserve someone who reviews them thoughtfully. Contrast and motion checks should fall to a named reviewer. And the final accessibility pass needs an accountable person before anything goes live. Without that clarity, tasks slip—not from a lack of care, but from uncertainty about who handles the final step.

    Tip: build a short “definition of done” for a video. If the checklist lives in the same place as your content calendar or project tickets, it gets used.

    Captions That Hold Up Under Review for YouTube Accessibility

    Captions are often treated like a marketing feature. They increase overall watch time. Search performance benefits. And viewers stay engaged, even in public settings. All true. But captions also carry a basic promise to Deaf and hard-of-hearing viewers. The promise is simple. The words matter, and you should be able to access them.

    Standards matter here, too. Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) includes caption requirements for prerecorded and live video. Auto-captions are rarely enough on their own. Names get dropped. Product terms get mangled. Key phrases come back as nonsense. If your content includes instructions, legal details, or health and safety steps, “close enough” captions can become a serious problem.

    Choose a Workflow You Can Repeat

    Your workflow can still be practical. In YouTube Studio, most teams choose one approach and stick with it:

    • Upload a caption file, like SRT or VTT, created in an editor or third-party tool.
    • Start with auto-captions, then edit and correct them.
    • Type captions in YouTube’s editor for shorter videos.

    What matters is consistency. Pick a standard and apply it. Many teams upload edited caption files for major videos and review auto-captions for low-risk clips. That can work, as long as “reviewed” means a real check.

    A quick quality checklist helps:

    • Accuracy: capture what is said, plus key sound cues when they change meaning
    • Timing: captions should appear with the speech, not late or early
    • Readability: short chunks, correct punctuation, and speaker labels when needed
    • Placement: do not cover critical visuals if you can avoid it

    Two caption details teams often miss:

    • Numbers and units: “15” vs “50” is not a small error in a demo or training video.
    • Proper nouns: product names, locations, and people’s names are where auto-captions tend to drift.

    Livestreams Need a Follow-Up Step

    Livestreams add pressure because content is happening in real time. Live captioning can still be useful, but it depends heavily on audio quality. Use a strong mic. Reduce background noise. Speak clearly. Then, when the livestream becomes an archived video, upload corrected captions. That keeps the recording usable long after the event ends.

    Transcripts and Chapters for YouTube Accessibility

    Captions are not the same as transcripts. Captions are synced to the video. Transcripts live outside the player. They let people scan, search, and jump to what they need.

    It helps to separate three things:

    • Captions: synced text that follows audio
    • Transcripts: full text of spoken content, not tied to exact timing
    • Descriptive transcripts: transcripts that also include important visual info

    Transcripts support more than disability access. They also help people who learn better by reading. For anyone who wants to revisit a specific tutorial step, a transcript makes it easy to review without rewatching the entire video. And when a user needs to search for a key phrase, the text lets them jump directly to the right section.

    Chapters Make Long Videos Easier to Navigate

    Chapters matter for the same reason. Long videos are easier to use when viewers can jump straight to what they need. For tutorials, webinars, and explainers, add timestamps and clear chapter titles. Skip vague labels like “Step 3.” Use names that match what a person is trying to do, like “Turn on captions in YouTube Studio” or “Fix timing and speaker labels.”

    A simple way to level up chapters is to write them like help-center headings. If the title sounds useful on a support page, it will likely be useful in a video, too.

    Bring Transcripts Onto Your Website

    If you embed videos on your website, do not hide the transcript behind extra clicks. Put the transcript on the page, or link to it right next to the player. This helps users decide if the video is worth watching. It also helps your site’s content, as the page now includes the same information in an easy-to-scan format.

    Audio Description for YouTube Accessibility

    Many teams assume audio description means a big budget and a separate production track. Sometimes it does. Often, it does not.

    The real question is whether the video includes meaningful visual details that are not shared in the audio. When a chart appears without explanation, that creates a gap. On-screen instructions that happen without being spoken create the same problem. And when important text is shown visually but never read aloud, that is another gap.

    Descriptive Narration Works Well for Demos

    In a talking-head video where the speaker explains everything, extra description may not be needed. But tutorials and demos are different. They rely on what the viewer sees. That is where descriptive narration becomes a strong option. The presenter can name what they are clicking, what changed on screen, and what the viewer should look for next.

    A helpful habit in demos is to replace vague phrases with concrete ones. Instead of “click this,” say “select Settings,” or “open the Captions tab,” or “choose English from the language menu.” That supports more viewers than you might expect, including people watching on small screens.

    Some teams also publish a second version, clearly labeled, like “with audio description,” when visuals are dense and constant. That approach can work well for training content, data-heavy explainers, or detailed product walkthroughs.

    Whether you use narration or a described version, keep descriptions concise and focused. Describe what changes the meaning. Place it in natural pauses. Keep the tone neutral and consistent with the video’s style.

    Visual Design Choices for YouTube Accessibility

    Video design can either support understanding or fight against it. Many accessibility issues show up in the same places, again and again. Thumbnails. On-screen text. Contrast. Motion.

    Contrast is a clear example. WCAG guidance uses targets like 4.5:1 for normal text and 3:1 for large text. Apply that mindset to thumbnails, titles, lower thirds, and callouts. If you need to place text over video footage, add a background block to keep it readable. Small text, thin fonts, and low contrast do not just look “clean.” They disappear for many viewers.

    Tip: if it is important enough to show, it is important enough to leave up long enough to read. Fast overlays are a common source of missed information.

    Reduce Flashing and Overly Fast Motion

    Motion is another common trap. Fast flashing edits and strobe-like overlays can create real harm for some people. Avoid rapid flashing effects. Keep motion smooth. If an edit feels intense, it probably is. Review the sequence before publishing.

    Do Not Rely on Color Alone

    Also, do not rely solely on color to convey meaning. If a chart uses red and green, add labels. If an overlay uses color to mark “good” and “bad,” add shapes or text. And if something important appears visually, say it out loud too. That single habit supports many people at once.

    Embedding and Ongoing Checks for YouTube Accessibility

    The standard YouTube embed gives you a lot. Player controls are built in. Keyboard operation is supported. The player adapts across screen sizes. Those are strong foundations.

    But your website still needs to do its part. An embedded video should not sit alone. Give it context:

    • A descriptive heading before the player
    • A short summary of what the video covers
    • A transcript on the page, or a clear link to it nearby

    Avoid auto-play when possible, especially with sound. Auto-play can overwhelm users and can make it harder for screen reader users to orient themselves on the page.

    Quick Checks to Add to QA

    Testing does not need to be complex. Build a few checks into QA:

    • Can you reach and operate the player with only a keyboard?
    • Does focus move in and out of the player in a predictable way?
    • Are captions available and working in the embedded view?
    • If you provide a described version, is it easy to find and understand?

    Hit Play on YouTube Accessibility

    Creating accessible YouTube content is not about chasing perfection or rebuilding your process from scratch. It is about making intentional choices that let more people engage with your videos, whether they are watching, listening, reading, or browsing. When captions are accurate, visuals are clear, and narration carries meaning, your content works harder and reaches further.

    At 216digital, we help teams turn accessibility from a checklist into a sustainable strategy. We work with you to integrate WCAG 2.1 accessibility requirements into your video and web development roadmap, tailored to your tools, timelines, and business goals. From reviewing existing video content to building repeatable workflows for captions, transcripts, and embedded media, our focus is on progress you can maintain.

    If you want guidance on strengthening your YouTube accessibility practices and aligning them with your digital accessibility goals, schedule a complimentary ADA Strategy Briefing with our team. We’ll help you make a plan that fits your team and your release cycles—on your terms.

    Greg McNeil

    December 12, 2025
    How-to Guides
    Accessibility, captions, Closed caption, How-to, screen readers, videos and audio content, Website Accessibility, Youtube
  • Captions or Subtitles: What’s the Difference?

    You’ve probably used them without a second thought—watching a movie in another language, scrolling social media with the sound off, or trying to follow dialogue in a noisy room. But have you ever noticed that sometimes the text includes sound effects and speaker names, while other times it’s just the spoken words?

    It’s easy to assume captions and subtitles are the same, but they serve different purposes. If you’ve ever struggled to keep up with fast dialogue or wished for more context in a quiet scene, you’ve already experienced the difference—maybe without even realizing it.

    So, what really sets them apart, and why does it matter? Let’s break it down.

    What Are Captions?

    Captions do more than just show dialogue—they make videos accessible for people who are deaf or hard of hearing. They include spoken words and crucial audio cues such as background noises, tone changes, and speaker identifications.

    Additionally, captions help content creators comply with important accessibility guidelines like the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG), the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), and Section 508.

    Types of Captions

    Closed Captions (CC) give viewers control to switch captions on or off and even adjust their appearance. Think YouTube, Netflix, or Zoom.

    Open Captions stay visible all the time. They’re perfect for social media videos, events, or public places where you can’t rely on viewers to activate captions themselves.

    What Are Subtitles?

    Subtitles primarily translate spoken words into another language for viewers who can hear but might not understand what’s being said. Unlike captions, subtitles typically skip audio cues and speaker names. They’re great for international movies or videos aimed at a global audience.

    Subtitles vs. Captions: Key Differences

    FeaturesCaptionsSubtitles
    PurposeAccessibility for Deaf/ Hard-of-hearingLanguage Translation
    Includes Sound Effects?YesNo
    Speaker Identification?YesNo
    Non-verbal Audio Cues?YesNo
    Assumes Viewer Can Hear?NoYes

    Why Are Captions Important for Web Accessibility?

    Captions create truly inclusive content accessible to everyone. Beyond meeting legal requirements, captions help businesses avoid compliance risks and potential lawsuits.

    But captions have benefits beyond compliance—they boost SEO by enabling search engines to index your video content effectively. They enhance viewer engagement, especially in quiet or noisy environments, and help non-native speakers follow along more easily, improving comprehension and retention.

    Open vs. Closed Captions: Which Should You Use?

    Choosing between open and closed captions depends on your content and audience.

    Open Captions are excellent for social media, live events, and public displays, where activating captions isn’t practical. They ensure every viewer can immediately access your message without additional steps.

    Closed Captions are ideal for platforms like YouTube or Netflix, where viewers prefer customizing their caption viewing experience. They’re also essential for educational videos, multilingual content, or professional presentations, where accuracy and personalization enhance viewer experience.

    How to Add Captions to Your Digital Content

    Adding captions can be straightforward, whether you choose manual or automated methods.

    Manual captioning involves creating captions yourself or with professional tools like Adobe Premiere Pro or YouTube Studio. This ensures accuracy and is highly recommended for educational and professional content.

    Automatic captioning services like YouTube auto-captions or platforms such as Rev.com provide quick results but may vary in accuracy. Always review and correct auto-generated captions to maintain quality and compliance.

    Understanding caption file formats is also beneficial. Popular formats include SRT (.srt), widely compatible across platforms like YouTube and Vimeo, and VTT (.vtt), ideal for web-based videos with additional formatting options.

    How to Add Captions

    • Create or auto-generate captions.
    • Review and edit carefully for accuracy.
    • Export the appropriate caption file.
    • Upload the caption file to your video platform

    Best Practices for Creating Accessible Captions

    • Prioritize Accuracy: Always proofread and edit captions.
    • Ensure Readability: Choose clear fonts and ensure strong contrast.
    • Be Concise and Clear: Keep captions brief but sufficient to communicate context.
    • Clearly Identify Speakers: Use identifiers like [John]: to clarify speakers.
    • Strategically Place Captions: Position captions without blocking essential visuals, typically at the bottom of the screen.

    Captions & Subtitles: Enhancing Your Content

    Captions and subtitles aren’t merely text overlays—they enhance viewer experiences, improve accessibility, and expand your content’s reach. By captioning thoughtfully, you’re making your videos richer and more inclusive.

    Looking to improve accessibility on your website? At 216digital, we’re ready to help. Reach out via our contact form below and schedule an ADA briefing. Let’s explore how we can elevate your digital presence and engagement together.

    Greg McNeil

    March 10, 2025
    WCAG Compliance
    Accessibility, captions, Closed caption, subtitles, videos and audio content, WCAG, WCAG Compliance, Web Accessibility
  • Closed Captions for Online Video Content

    With online video content becoming a cornerstone of business, marketing, and education, ensuring your videos are accessible to everyone is essential. One of the most effective ways to ensure your videos reach the widest audience possible is through closed captioning. But what exactly are closed captions? How do they work, and what actions must you take as a business or website owner? Let’s dive into everything you need to know about closed captions.

    What Are Closed Captions?

    Closed captions are text alternatives for words spoken in video or information conveyed through visual actions, designed to help people who are deaf or hard of hearing understand the content. Captions appear at the bottom of the frame and include the spoken dialogue and describe sound effects, music, or other audio cues critical to understanding the video. Closed captions can be toggled on and off by the video player, giving them control over how they experience the content.

    Who Benefits From Closed Captions?

    You might think closed captions are just for people with hearing impairments, but they benefit a much broader audience. Closed captions can help:

    • Deaf and hard-of-hearing individuals: This is the primary group that closed captions serve, allowing them to access video content on an equal footing with hearing viewers.
    • Non-native language speakers: Captions help people learning English or other languages follow along with the dialogue.
    • People in noisy environments: Imagine watching a video in a busy coffee shop or on public transportation—captions make it possible to follow along even if you can’t hear the audio.
    • People in quiet environments: Maybe you’re watching a video while a baby sleeps in the next room. With captions, you can follow the content without turning up the volume.

    Closed Captions vs. Subtitles: What’s the Difference?

    Though often used interchangeably, closed captions and subtitles aren’t quite the same. Subtitles are a text representation of the spoken words in a video. They benefit individuals with hearing impairments or people who can’t understand the spoken language but can otherwise visually perceive the content. For instance, subtitles often appear in foreign films. They don’t include sound effects or non-dialogue audio, which makes them less accessible for people who are deaf or hard of hearing.

    On the other hand, closed captions include not just the dialogue but also sound effects and other crucial audio information, making them more comprehensive.

    What are the Differences Between “Closed Captions” and “Open Captions”?

    You’ve likely heard about “closed captions” and “open captions.” The critical difference between the two is control. Closed captions can be toggled on or off by the viewer, while open captions are always on—they’re embedded into the video file and cannot be turned off. While open captions may seem convenient, they don’t provide viewers the choice to disable them, which can sometimes detract from the viewing experience for those who don’t need them.

    What Are the Legal Obligations for Closed Captioning?

    As a website owner, business owner, or content creator, you must understand your legal obligations regarding closed captions. In the U.S., several laws and regulations address digital accessibility, including captioning for video content.

    The ADA’s Requirements for Closed Captions

    The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) states that businesses and organizations make their services accessible to people with disabilities. While the ADA doesn’t specifically mention closed captions, it requires that public-facing businesses and websites provide equal access to their services, which can include providing captions for video content.

    The Department of Justice has provided guidance that websites should be accessible to everyone, and providing captions for videos is an integral part of ensuring your content meets the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG), which help businesses comply with the ADA.

    FCC Requirements for Closed Captions

    For online video content that has aired on TV in the U.S., the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) requires closed captions. This regulation was expanded in 2012 with the introduction of the Twenty-First Century Communications and Video Accessibility Act (CVAA), which requires that any video programming aired on television with captions must include captions when distributed online.

    This act means that if your business uses TV ads or commercials and also posts them online, they must be captioned. Even if your content hasn’t aired on TV, following FCC rules for captioning is a good best practice.

    What Are the Benefits of Using Closed Captioning?

    Adding closed captions to your videos isn’t just about legal compliance—it can offer significant benefits to your business:

    • Expanded audience: Captioning your videos makes them accessible to more people, including those with hearing impairments, non-native speakers, and people in noisy or quiet environments.
    • Improved SEO: Search engines can’t watch videos but can read captions. By adding captions, you give search engines more context to the relevance of your content, which can improve your rankings in search results.
    • Better engagement: Captions can help viewers stay engaged with your content. Studies have shown that videos with captions have higher engagement compared to those without.
    • Increased social media reach: Many social media platforms autoplay videos without sound. Captions can ensure your message gets across, even if the audio isn’t playing.

    Best Practices for Closed Captioning

    Here are some best practices for closed captioning video content:

    • Ensure the captions are accurate: Inaccurate captions can confuse viewers or misrepresent your content. Invest in high-quality captioning services or use tools that offer high accuracy.
    • Include non-dialogue audio: Remember that closed captions provide a complete audio experience for viewers who can’t hear. Include descriptions of music, sound effects, and other audio cues that are important to understanding the content.
    • Use appropriate timing: Ensure that captions appear on-screen at the same time as dialogue or actions.
    • Keep the text readable: Ensure the text is easy to read by using a legible font, high contrast between the text and background, and large enough size to be legible.

    How to Add Captions to Videos

    There are several ways to add captions to your videos, depending on the platform and your budget:

    1. Automated captioning tools: Platforms like YouTube and Facebook offer automatic captioning, though these tools often require manual review to ensure accuracy.
    2. Manual captioning: You can create captions manually if you have the resources. Many video editing tools allow you to add captions by entering the text.
    3. Professional captioning services: You should invest in a professional service specializing in closed captioning for high-quality, accurate captions. These services usually charge based on the length of the video.

    What If My Video Service Doesn’t Support Closed Captions?

    If your platform doesn’t support closed captions, consider switching to one that does. Most popular video hosting services, including YouTube, Vimeo, and Wistia, provide captioning options. If switching platforms isn’t feasible, you can include a transcript of the video as an alternative. However, this is not a perfect substitute for closed captions, as transcripts don’t provide the real-time viewing experience that captions do.

    Conclusion

    Closed captions are a great way to make online video content accessible to everyone, and they offer many benefits, from legal compliance to better engagement and SEO. As a business or website owner, adding captions to your videos can broaden your audience, improve your content’s reach, and ensure you’re providing a digital experience that’s inclusive to everyone.

    Remember to follow the ADA, FCC, and WCAG guidelines, and always aim for accuracy and readability when adding captions to your videos. If you’re unsure if your video content is leaving you vulnerable to expensive litigation or causing you to miss out on revenue, reach out to 216digital for a courtesy evaluation.

    Bobby

    September 24, 2024
    How-to Guides, Legal Compliance, The Benefits of Web Accessibility
    ADA Compliance, Closed caption, digital accessibility, How-to, WCAG, Web Accessibility, web development

Find Out if Your Website is WCAG & ADA Compliant







    216digital Logo

    Our team is full of expert professionals in Web Accessibility Remediation, eCommerce Design & Development, and Marketing – ready to help you reach your goals and thrive in a competitive marketplace. 

    216 Digital, Inc. BBB Business Review

    Get in Touch

    2208 E Enterprise Pkwy
    Twinsburg, OH 44087
    216.505.4400
    info@216digital.com

    Support

    Support Desk
    Acceptable Use Policy
    Accessibility Policy
    Privacy Policy

    Web Accessibility

    Settlement & Risk Mitigation
    WCAG 2.1/2.2 AA Compliance
    Monitoring Service by a11y.Radar

    Development & Marketing

    eCommerce Development
    PPC Marketing
    Professional SEO

    About

    About Us
    Contact

    Copyright 2024 216digital. All Rights Reserved.