Client Case Study

"We always had accessibility in mind": An ADA Lawsuit Case Study

Door County Coffee had accessibility in mind when they updated their website, and still received their first ADA accessibility lawsuit. This is Erin Hoffman's account of the remediation, and of the monthly scanning that has run ever since.

Every quotation on this page is reproduced verbatim and uncut from Erin Hoffman's own written answers about the engagement, published with permission and kept on file. Nothing has been paraphrased, shortened, or tightened.

Client
Door County Coffee

Industry
Coffee

eCommerce Platform
BigCommerce

Engagement
Remediation + ongoing monitoring

Quoted
Erin Hoffman, Director of eCommerce

Before: already trying, and sued anyway

Not every business that receives an accessibility claim had been ignoring the problem. Plenty have already done real work — alt text written, contrast corrected, a plugin reporting a clean score — and are caught out by the part automated checks are worst at: whether the site can be operated from the keyboard alone, what a screen reader announces during checkout, whether a form's error messages can be reached at all. A tool that reports no errors has not told you those things. Our demand letter response page covers what the first week actually looks like. Door County Coffee run their store on BigCommerce, where some of the markup is yours and some of it belongs to the platform; our BigCommerce accessibility page covers where that line falls.

When we were hit with our very first ADA Lawsuit, we were surprised and unsure what the immediate next steps should be. We always had accessibility in mind when updating the website and felt that we were doing the right thing to make the website accessible for all, but we quickly learned that there was still room for improvement. When we were connected with the team at 216, they explained everything to us and immediately helped us form a plan to resolve the issues present and get our website compliant and shoppable for all. They were a critical and important resource for us during this time and we could not have tackled the issues with confidence, without their support.

During: conversations before code

Remediation is code work, and most of it happens away from the client's team. What cannot be handed over is the judgement: which barriers a claim actually turns on, what a fix does to a design someone signed off, and what the business is prepared to maintain once we are gone. That is what the conversations are for, and it is the reason a scan report on its own is not a plan.

We appreciated the personal conversations and explanation of our situation and what we could do to work towards a resolution. It was wonderful to have partners in our corner to make sure that we were doing the right thing for our customers.

After: a monthly scan

A remediated site drifts. New products, seasonal content and theme updates reintroduce barriers, which is why this engagement did not end at the fix. a11y.Radar re-scans the site on a schedule and reports what changed, so the state of the site is something the team can look at rather than something they find out about from someone else.

We are now still contracted with 216 to run a with a monthly scan for us. This allows us to make sure we are staying on top of things and that our website remains accessible. This report and partnership give us the reassurance needed and a knowledgeable partner in our corner. Our expertise is coffee and 216's expertise is accessibility and they are a valued partner to make sure we are doing the right thing.

Find out what a scan actually says about your site

A briefing is free and carries no obligation. We scan your site, separate what a claim would realistically turn on from what a tool merely flagged, and set out what remediation would involve in your own code. If a demand letter is already in hand, bring your attorney into that conversation.

Contact Us

Another lawsuit engagement is written up as our small business remediation case study, and a third grew into a full accessibility program with training and monitoring. See all client case studies, or a11y.Radar for the monitoring itself.